Macaroni and Cheese - Community Q style - UPDATED 2.0

So, in our continuing search for the perfect macaroni and cheese, we have attempted to reach the holy grail of mac and cheese in Atlanta, and that is Community Q. Some argue that Community Q is a Mac and Cheese restaurant disguised as a BBQ joint. It is by far the best we have had, and on holidays we regularly go pick some up to go for a side. However, this Thanksgiving we were faced with a sold-out situaish. So, let's make it ourselves. SEE RED FOR UPDATES.

Research:

Located the recipe from one of the owners back when they worked elsewhere. It is HERE.

Ingredients:

16 oz Rigatoni noodles
UPDATED TO 2.25 CUPS
8 oz Monterey Jack cheese
8 oz Cheddar cheese
4 oz Parmesan cheese

Don't get too fancy with the ingredients here. It is mac and cheese, so use staple store brands.

Execution:

Boil some water

Salt the water - as salty as the sea  and then some (extra salty) - and add noodles. Follow the box.

In the meantime, grate up some cheese. All the cheddar and the Jack and then a cup of the Parmesan.

Drain the noodles but don't rinse

.

Mix in all the cream and half the cheese and stir

Then place in a shallow pan - UPDATED TO A DEEPER PAN

Sprinkle on some extra parmesan and the remaining cheese 

Bake at 350 for 30 minutes

Enjoy!

Verdict:

It was a little dry. I think that the recipe was fine, but we used a pan that was too big and spread the mac and cheese too thin with too much surface area - it isn't how they make it in the store. Next time, we will use a smaller and deeper pan and keep the mac and cheese a little thicker with less surface area. Otherwise, the taste was perfect. We will do this again without modifying the recipe.

Standby we will update this.

UPDATED TO DEEPER PAN AND LITTLE MORE CREAM. THIS WAS PERFECT!! ALSO NEEDS TO REST FOR 20 MINUTES OR SO.

We would love it if you would drop us a note in the comment section and let us know how your cook went. We are always looking for suggestions and improvements! We have opened up the comments so that anyone can post now, so please do. I'll try not to delete anything unless it is spam or stabs me in the heart.

Please help support our site, buy something you like on Amazon. Simply click through the links below and though you can pick anything, I suggest the thermometer and knives below:

So apparently Thermoworks doesn't sell through Amazon anymore. You must buy direct. Still the thermometer to have. Go here and order direct. unfortunately, we don't get a dime for this but still, it is one you want.

Aaron Franklin's Favorite trimming knife:

Dexter-Russell (S131F-6PCP) - 6" Boning Knife - Sani-Safe Series

Aaron Franklin's Favorite Brisket cutting/serving knife:

Sani-Safe S140-12SC-PCP 12" Scalloped Roast Slicer